We're sorry to say, but your grandma's green bean casserole is tame. Flip open a 19th-century cookbook, and the menu gets wild: booze-laced pumpkin pudding, pies made with vinegar, and turkeys stuffed with seafood.
Pull up a chair. Here is a five-course tour of vintage Thanksgiving recipes that real families once served, each one more surprising than the last.
The 1871 household guide Common Sense in the Household by Marion Harland includes a recipe for cranberry wine. Mashed berries soak in water for a couple of days, get strained, then sit with extra fruit and ferment in jars.
No sparkling cider here. This was a do-it-yourself fermentation project on the holiday table.
Today, oysters mean a pricey appetizer. For centuries they were everyday food.
A handwritten early cookbook held by the Folger Shakespeare Library calls for a boiled turkey stuffed with chopped oysters, breadcrumbs, suet, anchovy, lemon peel, mace, and nutmeg. It's a salty, savory surprise for anyone expecting sage and celery.
Turkey wasn't always the star. Early American feasts leaned on whatever birds were around, including duck and goose.
In 1885, Juliet Corson's New Family Cook Book tells cooks to roast a duck packed with herbed mashed potatoes and serve it with currant jelly and butter. That's stuffing and sides in one bird.
Eliza Leslie's 1828 cookbook gives pumpkin a grown-up makeover. Her pudding mixes stewed pumpkin with spices, eggs, and sugar, then adds wine, brandy, and rose water before baking in pastry. Think of it as pumpkin pie's perfumed, tipsy ancestor.
What do you bake when winter arrives, and the fruit is gone? Frontier cooks answered with vinegar pie: a filling of vinegar, molasses, water, and flour that stood in for fruit.
Later versions added eggs, butter, and sugar, and bakers still make it. Some even use apple cider vinegar for a tangy taste!
What foods were served at Thanksgiving in the 1800s? It depended on region and budget. Roasted birds, oyster stuffing, pumpkin desserts, and homemade fruit drinks all appear in 19th-century cookbooks.
Is vinegar pie a real old-fashioned dessert? Yes. Frontier cooks made it when fresh fruit ran out, and it's still baked today.
Every strange recipe above reflects what people had on hand: cheap oysters, leftover fruit, a jug of vinegar. Our own traditions are likely to seem just as odd to future generations. Someday, someone will read about marshmallow-topped sweet potatoes and ask, "They ate that ?"
Weird food isn't just history. In Phoenix, Arizona, pizza maker Nick Yatsinko paints edible art right onto the cheese with food coloring. Cartoons, celebrities, you name it. He started painting slices to draw customers into his restaurant, and it worked!
Now people order custom "master-pizzas" that are almost too cool to eat. Discover more oddities like Nick's in Ripley's Wired Into Weird .
Ripley's Believe It or Not!
Step into the world of Ripley’s Believe It or Not!, where truth is always stranger than fiction! Bui…
By this author
5 Foods Named After Real People: The Strange Stories Behind Them
Hold the Anchovies, Pass the Paintbrush: This Phoenix Pizza Maker Paints on Cheese
Hot Dogs by the Numbers: Fourth of July Traditions
